About 5 years ago I picked up a book called “The Motivation Breakthrough” by Richard Lavoie. In this book, Lavoie explores six different techniques that help to initiate the engagement of children in learning: the “6 P’s” of Praise, Power, Projects, Prestige, Prizes and People. I have often considered these techniques as a guidance counsellor working with struggling students. For example, do we need to hook a socially isolated student in by making them feel important (praise) and/or feel connected (people)? For the student having a tough time completing assignments, do we simply need to enact a good old reward system to help reinforce good orderly direction (prizes)?
But this consideration doesn’t just have to apply to students who are struggling. In fact, when I think about Student Leadership I find myself asking similar questions. What is motivating these students to take on formal leadership roles? As I look at Lavoie’s “6 P’s” I am struck by how often our students see the role of School Captain, Prefect or House Captain as an opportunity to gain praise, power, projects, prestige, prizes and a connection to people – all of them extrinsic reasons. But the “P” that I wish I saw more often is much more intrinsic: passion; passion to give back to their community, to serve their school and to take on portfolios that they have been pursuing for years.
But how much of this is the fault of the student? We work in schools where we elevate the role of the Formal Student Leader through praise (assemblies, announcements), power (allowing certain privileges that others may not get), projects (fun, high profile portfolios), prestige (they are made to feel important), prizes (special belts and ties) and people (first-past-the-post election process, sometimes seen as a popularity contest). Are we delivering a mixed message when we try to tell them to be less extrinsically motivated as they apply to formal leadership positions given the structures, traditions and cultures surrounding their allure?
There are some traditions that will certainly not change overnight. But I think a concerted effort to look at the things that we do that continue to promote extrinsic reasons to engage in student leadership is important. One of the goals that we have this year at Havergal is to consider “passion” as we try to gear students towards taking on certain portfolios at the school. Also, is it possible to elevate “small-l” leadership as much as ‘’big-l” leadership? And how do we do that without the promise of praise, power, projects, prestige, prizes, and people?

Hi @vwade!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I think that your question will be well understood by many in our schools. Too often we see students participating in leadership, sports, etc. for the wrong reasons. Back when I was in Guidance, one of the first questions I’d ask my students when they submitted their applications for leadership positions was “why are you applying?” If they told me that it was because it would look good on their resume, they should reconsider because doing things just for their resume was not a good enough reason.
I think I’d add another two P’s to your list: perceived pressure. Many of these students who planned to attend Ontario Universities were under the false assumption that having all of these activities on their resumes would boost their post-secondary chances, when in reality most of them were applying to programs that had no supplemental application or resume required. A big question I find myself asking is how might we redefine the admissions process, to allow for student passion, perseverance, and potential shine through?
So much food for thought! I’d love to hear how other schools are dealing with these big questions.
Hi Les, your added two P’s are so very true. We try to encourage students, as they start to ask questions about the university admissions process, to follow their passion when getting involved in leadership, co-curriculars, volunteer work, etc..and not get sucked into the idea of “checking boxes” but I think it’s tough because many students have no clue what their passion is and it stresses them out even more that they should know. I think this adds to the perceived pressure that they face.
This is an interesting exploration of motivation, Vanessa. Increasing the intrinsic motivation of students has been a goal of mine. I’d love to learn about proven techniques for this from the trenches; from other teachers who have tried something and noted positive changes in the students with whom they work. Carrots and sticks frustrate me, and these these 6Ps can definitely have an extrinsic source. In Drive, Pink wrote about autonomy, mastery, and purpose. I wonder if a bit more autonomy over student systems of leadership would help. Pink discussed autonomy via another acronym, 4Ts: task, time, technique and team. How might we increase student autonomy over leadership tasks, the time they spend on those tasks, the techniques by which they accomplish the tasks, and the team with which they work when they take on leadership roles? Maybe the answer lies within Pink’s ideas somewhere?
Strange. I thought I had already replied to this, but there is nothing here. Perhaps there is an approval step. Here is a useful link about the 4Ts and leadership: http://coach4leadership.com/2015/07/21/how-to-leverage-the-4-ts-of-autonomy-to-fuel-internal-motivation/
Awesome. Thanks for sending this. I haven’t read Drive – it’s one that I am for sure going to be adding to my booklist!
Venessa, thank you for posting this blog. Your points about igniting passion and intrinsic motivation are very well made. Perhaps linking passion to character strengths and helping students discover their “best selves” might be a springboard? Young people may not have well-defined passions (yet) and helping them discover what truly “fills their cup” could be a great conversation starter. I’m interested in how you make change at Havergal.
Thanks Emilia – thank you for your comment and I do think that a workshop in Grade 9, 10 and/or 11 on the students’ values and character would be helpful to guide them towards various leadership roles (be it formal or informal).
Great discussion thread going on here about Leadership which tells me that this is resonating. This links to some of the work of you @lfarooq and what others have looked at in the past about passion and praise.
What is resonating with me about this post from @vwade is how leadership is tied up with expectations (real and perceived) about what students feel pressure to accomplish in High School, in order to accomplish their goal (albeit one of delayed gratification) of happiness (albeit a narrowly defined version of happiness).
When asked, students tend to say, I want to be a leader to make a difference. Although, when asked for examples, they cite things that they could accomplish without formal leadership roles.
What Vanessa and I are shifting towards is “service to others”. That means, as a prefect, house captain, or grad president, etc… you are taking on a portfolio through which you serve the larger school. The real question is how much do the students feel this responsibility to the school?
Also, how much time and dedication are we – as faculty mentors throughout the school – providing our students to learn, do and reflect on leadership?
Anyone got any ideas to share?
Thanks for this great post and for these comments @lfarooq @jmedved @emartin @lmcbeth
garth.
Well if there was ever a worthy action plan focus…this is it.
I love the idea of not taking leadership opportunities at face value but rather push the idea of leadership “responsibility” and dig into how we might make that ring true and authentically for our student leaders.
Looping @lmcbeth @tfaucher @mmosun @timrollwagen in here as they have lots to share from their schools.
@vwade What an amazing Action Plan to tackle. I love the way you said, “But the “P” that I wish I saw more often is much more intrinsic: passion; passion to give back to their community, to serve their school and to take on portfolios that they have been pursuing for years.” I think @lmcbeth‘s idea of perceived pressure plays a key role in these decisions for our students. I wonder, how might we give our students the time and space to discover what they are truly passionate about? How can we help them to realize that once they find their passion, see their potential and persevere (@lmcbeth‘s other p’s) with their ideas for service and leadership, that the experience that they can speak to and personal growth will far outweigh a list of big-L titles on their application?
Thank Sam. I think one of the places where we can give time and space for reflection is in our TA time (morning advisory/homeform). The problem is that there are so many competing priorities for this time. I think simply starting the conversation when they are younger, and not just in Grade 10-12 is a good start.